Jenny’s story: Thumb surgery eases hand pain

Friday, August 20, 2021

By: Femi Cole

Related Medical Services:

Jenny Brotherton


Jenny Brotherton was fed up with the pain in her left hand. She felt it every time she tried to do things she wanted or needed to do around the house. She was fed up with the inconveniences it caused.


“It impacted a lot of the things that you would normally take for granted, like washing dishes or doing laundry or holding a hair dryer or a flat iron to style my hair,” she says. “Even tying shoes. Just real simple things.”


Brotherton needed help. She asked her long-term physical therapist for advice.


He recommended an old friend, Dr. Brian J. Klika, a fellowship-trained hand surgeon with Orthopedics & Sports Medicine BayCare Clinic. Brotherton’s physical therapist and Klika knew one another from college. The therapist knew Klika could provide the care Brotherton needed.


Klika diagnosed Brotherton with advanced left thumb carpometacarpal and scaphotrapeziotrapezoidal arthritis. It was the reason for her pain, stiffness and weakness, impaired hand function and reduced strength and dexterity. Brotherton’s thumb joint cartilage had worn away, resulting in painful bone-on-bone arthritis.


Her condition was so severe that all conservative treatment options failed. That’s when Klika recommended surgery.


“He wasn’t pushing me into anything and he wasn’t sugar-coating anything,” Brotherton says. “He was very up front and said, ‘The goal is not to get you back to 100 percent because it’s not going to happen.’ I was at about 20 to 30 percent. He kinda put it in a simple mathematical equation. ‘Here’s where you’re at and if we can maybe get you up to 80 percent or so, what would that do for you?’ He made sure I had a very realistic understanding of what was and wasn’t possible.”


Brotherton had thumb surgery in December 2020. Klika removed the arthritis and performed a suspensionplasty which allowed scar tissue to form while stabilizing the joint.


After surgery, Brotherton worked with an occupational therapist and received follow-up care from Lacey Jandrin, a physician assistant with Orthopedics & Sports Medicine BayCare Clinic.


Brotherton experienced some swelling shortly after her procedure but by her two-week post-surgery checkup, she was feeling better and received positive feedback from Jandrin.


“Lacey had told me that my range of motion at that point was fantastic,” Brotherton says. “Both the therapist and Lacey said, ‘Wow, your range of motion is well beyond what most people have at this point in time in their recovery.'"


At her final follow-up appointment, approximately four months after surgery, Brotherton was doing exceptionally well and was able to participate in activities pain free.


“I can’t imagine a better outcome,” she says.


Dr. Brian J. Klika sees patients in Green Bay, Manitowoc and Kaukauna. To request an appointment, call 920-288-5555 in Green Bay, 877-618-6676 in Manitowoc, 877-884-8796 in Kaukauna, or do so online.


© 2022 BayCare Clinic.

All Rights Reserved.

BayCare Clinic,, is the largest physician-owned specialty-care clinic in northeastern Wisconsin and Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. It is based in Green Bay, Wisconsin. BayCare Clinic offers expertise in more than 20 specialties, with more than 100 physicians serving in 16 area communities. BayCare Clinic is a joint partner in Aurora BayCare Medical Center, a 167-bed, full-service hospital. Follow BayCare Clinic on Facebook and Twitter.